At the Spartan Invitational Golf Tournament on April, 24, 2009, Cayuga earned the region's best-ever overall second-place finish with a team score of 315. An eight-team field competed at Highland Park Golf Club in Auburn. Brian Walker tied for second-best round of the day with his team-best 75. In his fourth top-ten finish in as many matches, Ryan May carded a 78 to tie for sixth overall. Rounding out the Cayuga scorecard were Caleb Gordon (80), Bill Moore (82), James Nervina (87), Shawn Patterson (88) and Nick DeSocio (95). Monroe CC won the event by shooting 300, with Tyler Phillips shooting an even-par 71 to earn medalist honors.